# Checkpoint 259 — BE-035 technical proposal review and revision

**Date:** 2026-10-26  
**Story status:** PARTIAL  
**Traceability:** 17 DONE, 121 PARTIAL, 16 MISSING, 10 BLOCKED (164 stories; DONE remains 10.4%).

CRM technical proposal drafts now have a company-scoped independent Sales Manager/Owner review in React and Odoo. A reviewer may approve for internal release, reject with a rationale, or request changes. A revision creates a new pending suggestion with original customer headings and source citations retained; the prior draft is cancelled and linked to the replacement. Odoo stores one immutable decision event per reviewed version and checks reviewer role, non-self-review, company/opportunity visibility, current source revision and citation allowlist. Review does not apply a suggestion, change the opportunity, create a quotation, or send/release a customer document.

## Verification

- Full isolated Odoo regression: **371 tests, 0 failures, 0 errors**. Focused technical-proposal suite: **7 tests, 0 failures, 0 errors**.
- Backend suite: **236 passed, 2 skipped** (265 subtests). Focused proposal-route checks passed.
- React unit suite: **80 passed**. Focused Playwright: **2 passed** for draft persistence and independent review; Vite production build passed.
- Native tests verify approve/reject/revise, immutable rationale, independent reviewer, self-review denial, stale-source denial, original-citation-only revisions, and unchanged quotation/order counts.
- Browser screenshot is synthetic fixture evidence, not authenticated live-role acceptance.

## Local demo rollout

- Before upgrading the shared local demo, saved `/tmp/namaa_ksa_before_be035_20261026.dump` (10,842,295 bytes, mode 0600).
- Upgraded `namaa_ai_bridge` on `namaa_ksa` to **20.0.1.0.27**. The addon reports installed at that version and Odoo `/web/login?db=namaa_ksa` returns HTTP 200.
- Rebuilt/restarted React and BFF. React `/`, BFF `/api/health/live`, Odoo login and local/public `/demo.html` returned HTTP 200.
- The public page served Checkpoint 259, current story totals, QA JSON, screenshot and traceability links (all HTTP 200).

## Remaining acceptance

BE-035 remains PARTIAL pending an authenticated two-user React→BFF→Odoo journey on a disposable clone, ordinary Sales Manager/Owner role and company/project matrix, Arabic review, customer-specific approval authority, PDF/archive/release linkage (BE-036), and full A1–A4. The approval role is provisional under DEC-26. No customer send is implemented.

See [QA evidence](CRM_TECHNICAL_PROPOSAL_REVIEW_QA.json), [review screenshot](frontend/screenshots/crm-technical-proposal-review-synthetic.png), [test results](../TEST_RESULTS.md), and [story matrix](../REQUIREMENTS_TRACEABILITY.md).
