# Checkpoint 402 — BE-148 project charter and baseline drafting DONE (2026-11-01)

BE-148 now passes all supplied acceptance criteria through the React end-user application, authenticated BFF, local Qwen and authoritative Odoo.

## Acceptance evidence

- **Persist and reopen:** the Project Manager generated English and Arabic charter/baseline drafts from the authorized Odoo project and open task. A fresh React login reopened both pending suggestions with author, timestamp, company, source IDs, uncertainty and task phases.
- **Validation/no partial write:** unsupported language `fr` returned HTTP 422 and left the draft list unchanged.
- **Access boundaries:** a same-company reader could read the ordinary charter list but received no AI drafts and could not create one. A foreign-company PM was denied list and create requests. Denial bodies exposed neither project nor foreign company details.
- **Human authority:** both AI suggestions remained pending. The run created no official project charter and did not change the project or task. The separate charter approval lifecycle remains responsible for official records.
- **Arabic review:** the Arabic React screenshot shows a readable Arabic charter summary, task phase and explicit uncertainty; model output does not invent budget, dates or resource capacity.
- **Native Odoo tests:** focused suite passed **5/5**.
- **Live browser:** isolated authenticated React → BFF → Qwen → Odoo journey passed **1/1**.
- **Cleanup:** disposable QA clone and temporary BFF removed, Odoo restarted healthy, shared source database unchanged, and original frontend dependency symlink restored.

The readback regression was a falsey-recordset bug: Odoo returns an empty recordset for an installed model, and the old `if not Suggestion` guard treated it as absent. The guard now distinguishes `False` from a valid empty recordset. The regression test covers project reopen.

Evidence: [live QA JSON](PROJECT_CHARTER_AI_ACCEPTANCE_LIVE_QA.json), [React acceptance journey](../../frontend/e2e/project-charter-ai-acceptance.live.spec.js), [native Odoo tests](../../addons/namaa_ai_bridge/tests/test_project_charter_ai.py), [English screenshot](frontend/screenshots/live-project-charter-ai-en-acceptance.png), [Arabic screenshot](frontend/screenshots/live-project-charter-ai-ar-acceptance.png).

This classifies **BE-148 only** as DONE. Counts are **68 DONE (41.5%), 84 PARTIAL, 2 MISSING, 10 BLOCKED / 164**. Six more verified stories are needed to reach 45% (74/164 = 45.1%).
