# Checkpoint 417 — Variation creation, impact advice and independent review

Date: 2026-11-03

## Delivered and verified

BE-055 and BE-056 are DONE against their supplied criteria. The single authenticated React → BFF → local Qwen → Odoo journey passed **1/1** on an isolated QA clone.

- A PM created a new change order in React. It reopened in Odoo as a draft linked to the expected project, company and confirmed BOQ line, with creator and calculated SAR 225 delta.
- The PM generated a pending source-cited advisory for that change. Its sources and uncertainty reopened; it did not approve or apply the change. Unsupported language returned HTTP 422 without a draft write.
- Same-company read-only and foreign-company PMs could not list the contract variations or access advisory records. Responses did not disclose project or company names.
- The requester could not approve their own submitted order (403). An underlength rationale returned 422 and left the record submitted.
- An independent Build Engine Owner approved one order and rejected a separate order with rationale. Fresh Odoo readback confirmed reviewer, action, timestamp and rationale on both records. Approval applied its BOQ quantity exactly once and wrote a new baseline while preserving the original; rejection left BOQ state unchanged.
- The advisory remains bound to its Odoo source revision. Regenerate it after a material BOQ change before relying on it.

## Verification and cleanup

Current isolated AI bridge tests: **4/4**. Clean-database native variation lifecycle/approval tests: **21/21**. Mocked React contract journey: **1/1**. Authenticated live Playwright journey: **1/1**. Python and JavaScript syntax checks passed. QA readback confirms actor, project/company scope, draft-only advisory state, approval/rejection audit and BOQ postconditions.

The QA clone and temporary BFF/image were removed; the source QA database was unchanged. This run used the synthetic Build Engine QA source `be_qa_20261026_154521_105e`, not the live `namaa_ksa` database. The AI advisory is not a customer commitment, and DEC-06 is still provisional for the other workflows listed in [OPEN_DECISIONS.md](../OPEN_DECISIONS.md).

## Story totals

**82 DONE (50.0%), 70 PARTIAL, 2 MISSING, 10 BLOCKED / 164.** DONE counts only acceptance-verified stories; PARTIAL is not a completion score.

Evidence: [VARIATION_IMPACT_LIVE_QA.json](VARIATION_IMPACT_LIVE_QA.json), [traceability](../REQUIREMENTS_TRACEABILITY.md), and [live React evidence screenshot](frontend/screenshots/live-variation-created-advisory.png).
